Friday, 23 January 2015

The Architecture of the City

Book Notes:

The Architecture of the City by Aldo Rossi Published 1978.

The introduction by Peter Eisenmann gives cause for discussion as to whether he is a part of the Italian tradition of Architect and Author.
The book, written over a period of years, begun 1966 from a lectures/ notes. The structure of the text reflects this.
Italy has a history of Architect as Writer, to augment, validate, review and predict their own and others' work. It would be reasonable to assume, the definition of Architecture from an Italian point of view is more expansive than Australia's.
  • Vitruvius
  • Alberti
  • Palladio
  • Serlio(?)
  • writings of Milizan, Lodoli, Siamozzi

The labyrinth, representational as a place for transformation.

Dialectics

  • remembering/ forgetting
  • public/ private
  • history/ memory
  • individual/ collective memory
  • rational design/ locus
The analogous city is a subversive act upon the real city. “A corrosive agent”
Rossi's work involves 2 types of transformations
DISLOCATION of place. shift ----> typological invention
DISSOLUTION of scale. The micro and the macro become somewhat interchangeable. [P.E. Takes issue with this, considers this akin to Alberti's humanism]
The change of scale can be independent or create independence of meaning. (quality?)
There are parallel scales in operation, [in Rossi's work] different time periods. Houses (micro) Housing Districts (macro).
The use of analogy allows for memory AND history.
“analogy expresses itself through a process of architectural design whose elements are pre-existant and formally defined, but whose true meaning is unforeseen at the beginning and unfolds only at the end of the process. Thus the meaning of the process is identified with the meaning of the city.” 1
This is far from a circular, self referential statement glibly suggesting some form of retrospective justification of an ad hoc design process, but one where objects are local, granular, and combined to coalesce into a greater urban whole. The outcome is a DNA unique to place. The act of combination of these elements is not a neutral act.
For Eisenmann, drawing, like writing (perhaps also building???), is an autonomous object.

3rd YEAR TASK:

Look for and map the cultural artefacts of Melbourne. (church, cemetery, library, pub, house, factory, monument).
The placement of monuments creates a cultural net across a city, a landscape. They anchor culture to the geography of site, and frame place. Monuments are primary artefacts. Unchanging.
Artefacts can be propelling or pathological. A catalyst. A locus is a component of an artefact.

“To each myth there is an underlying permanent reality”
Preserving myth is a key to understanding the meanings of monuments.
History is alive it is the continuing connection of object to function and event. Disconnection of history from object results in only memory. (individual and cultural).
“History exists so long as an object is in use, that is, so long as a form relates to its original function. However when form and function are severed, and only form remains vital, history shifts into the realms of memory”.2
“Form is urban history, the succession of events, constitutes its memory. The soul of a city. Once this soul is given form, it becomes the sign of place. Memory becomes the guide to its structure.”

“Analogy is Rossi's most important apparatus.”3

[2nd Para pp.8 discuss...]

  • The city = construction over time.
  • The city IS an artefact.
  • The city is a theatre of human events


For Rossi, there are 2 key methods of reading the city.
  1. City as a product of generative functional systems of its architecture. -political, social, economic...
  2. City as a spatial structure – architecture form + geography
The city is information, of data made manifest. More than a palimpsest.
Economics, politics, power, the architect is NOT a neutral subject / agent.4
There is a melancholy in Rossi's writing in the description of post war European cities. His description of Berlin is akin to skeletal remains of many of Calvino's Invisible Cities.
Post WWII killed the purity of pre-war modernism. Killed the promise.
My new word: Conshumanism
Humanism: subject + object
Modernism: subject [process] object
The architectural process is not neutral. Process + object develops typology – becomes verb(?)
Process includes history it is skeletal, it implies both structure and ruin. (image: coral reef)

Further Reading related from this text:

  • Aristotle/ Plato's Republic: compare the different positions of each.
  • Jacques Derrida: Writing and Difference (take a deep breath!)
  • Ferdinand de Saussure: Linguistics.
  • Bernard Tschumi: Event Cities
  • Italo Calivino: Invisible Cities. a KEY text here. Much of what he writes is echoed by Rossi. Q:Who's first?
1Rossi, pp.18
2Peter Eisenmann, pp.7
3Ibid pp.8

4Peter Eisenmann, pp.5

No comments:

Post a Comment